Good News/Bad News: Court Rules No Autism Vaccine Link

It is important news, but it’s hardly surprising:

A federal appeals court denied the existence of a link between vaccines and autism, specially the MMR. Autism is a disorder that affects 1 in 110 children in the United States. A special vaccines court was held last year and the appeals court upheld the decision that the evidence was weak and contradictory.

It’s good news for the simple fact that it’s nice to see when a court rules in favor of the scientific evidence.

It’s bad news because we should not be looking to courts to determine what the science says about subjects! And this isn’t because I am biased against courts. It’s just that the court room is traditionally one of the least scientific places in the known universe.

In the court room, one of the most powerful and convincing forms of evidence is eye-witness testimony. But scientists know (and even some non-scientists like yours truly) that eye-witness testimony is the worst form of evidence there is.

On a witness stand, however, a mother or father who is sincerely upset and confused and angry about the condition their child has is infinitely more moving and convincing than cold facts and figures. Because humans are by no means perfect logical and rational animals. We let our emotions rule us quite a lot of the time…and that isn’t a judgment, just an observation.

The problem is that when we let emotions rule the day, as often happens in front of even the best judges and juries, it is so easy to come up with the factually wrong conclusion.

It’s nice when they get it right. But it still scares me when we look to them for the answers.

This entry was posted in Medicine, Science and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Good News/Bad News: Court Rules No Autism Vaccine Link

  1. marchmommie7 says:

    I love studying about Autism. Have you read the Temple Grandin story? Have you read about the studies scientists have done concerning Camel’s milk and Autism?

  2. Jen Quon says:

    Really good post. I have a child with autism (aspergers) and have never believed it had anything to do with vaccines. Not because I really even knew the medical arguments, but I chose to believe that way – I always felt it was a way of trying to place blame for something that we (parents) can’t control.

    “The problem is that when we let emotions rule the day, … it is so easy to come up with the factually wrong conclusion.”

    A very true statement indeed.

  3. extro1 says:

    Hi there, great blog and always nice to meet a like-minded thinker. I posted an article about this whole anti-vaccination campaign if you are interested.

    Keep fightin the good fight,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s